
Both are newcomers to the province and are planning how to secure a comfortable retirement while managing their present-day living costs.
At present the pair rents a unit in the Greater Toronto Area. Their long-term plan includes retiring at age 60 with an annual income target of $100,000. Together they earn $210,000 before taxes, and Tony receives a pension payment of $3,400 each month from a former employer, while his current employment provides an additional, yet uncertain, pension component.
Weighing the Options: Buy or Rent in Toronto
The couple also owns three rental properties located in Calgary, collectively valued at $1.865 million. The mortgages on those assets are scheduled to be paid off around the time they intend to retire. They are evaluating three distinct pathways: retaining all three rentals while renting a home in Toronto, liquidating the entire Calgary portfolio to fund a purchase in the city, or selling only the condo portion and using the proceeds to acquire a residence in the Greater Toronto Area.
They have expressed interest in exchange-traded funds and other investment vehicles, emphasizing the need for assets that can appreciate over time while supporting their retirement cash flow.
An adviser notes that, based on the numbers the couple has supplied, their current trajectory would produce an annual retirement income of $130,000. However, the adviser cautions that the figures may be optimistic and suggests a thorough verification of pension projections. The adviser also points out that the Canada Pension Plan offset could reduce the amount Tony expects to receive from his defined-benefit plan.
Read Also: Canada’s Drone Industry Surges with Federal Funding Boost
If the couple chooses to sell the entire set of Calgary properties, they would forfeit approximately $80,000 in yearly rental revenue. That loss could create a shortfall that their remaining investments might not be able to bridge. Keeping the rentals, therefore, appears to preserve a steady income stream that can bolster their retirement budget.
When comparing the financial impact of renting versus buying, the adviser outlines a scenario involving a home priced at $750,000. With a down payment of $100,000, the remaining mortgage would be $650,000. Monthly housing costs in that situation would total more than the amount they would spend on rent. The adviser suggests that allocating the difference to an investment portfolio could accumulate funds over a 15-year horizon, potentially generating income once they retire.
A $750,000 home today with three per cent growth should be worth about $1.2 million in 15 years, said the adviser. However, from a retirement income perspective, the adviser notes that keeping the rental properties is a better option, as selling them would cost the couple an anticipated $80,000 a year in rental income in retirement.
The adviser’s advice: “Become comfortable with equity investments to get a more comfortable retirement. And when it comes to rental properties, when the mortgage is down to less than half the value of the property, it’s typically better to sell the property and invest the proceeds in equity investments.” In conclusion, the couple should carefully consider their options and prioritize their retirement goals to make an informed decision about their financial future. *Names have been changed to protect privacy. Do you have a wealth building question for Family Finance? Email [email protected].